
ABC Information Photograph Illustration / Win McNamee / Getty Photos
In his presidential marketing campaign, Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis has pitched himself as a transformational chief who has reshaped the politics of his dwelling state. His 2022 reelection by 19 proportion factors “was not only a huge victory,” he has argued. “It was actually a basic realignment of Florida from being a swing state to being a pink state.” And most political evaluation agrees that the Sunshine State, as soon as identified for its impossibly shut elections, is now a comfortably Republican-leaning state.
But it surely’s unclear how a lot credit score DeSantis himself deserves for this shift — or if it even counts as a realignment in any respect. Essentially the most distinguished argument in his favor, that Republicans have moved to the state due to his COVID-19 insurance policies, is tough to show. His funding within the state GOP seems to have paid actual dividends, however a number of different components contributed to that push’s success. He in all probability didn’t have a lot to do with one other considered one of Florida Republicans’ greatest accomplishments over the previous few years: their inroads with Hispanic voters.
And at last, there’s appreciable doubt over whether or not DeSantis’s premise — that Florida will proceed to be a secure Republican state going ahead — is even appropriate. The information suggests DeSantis’s 2022 rout was a historic outlier, pushed by an enormous partisan turnout hole, and it’s unwise to make sweeping pronouncements based mostly on only one election.
‘Political refugees’ may not be such a game-changer
Ask many Florida Republicans, and so they’ll inform you Florida has gotten redder as a result of DeSantis’s well-known opposition to COVID-19 restrictions through the pandemic drew anti-lockdown Republicans to the state in droves. “COVID, and Gov. DeSantis’s insurance policies that had been applied throughout COVID, is in my opinion chargeable for the deeper shade of pink that Florida has now turn into,” mentioned Justin Sayfie, a distinguished Florida Republican political guide.
The issue with this idea is that Florida’s inhabitants was already increasing even earlier than COVID-19 hit. It’s true that the pandemic had a very huge impression on Florida: In line with American Neighborhood Survey estimates, 674,740 folks moved to Florida from a special state or the District of Columbia in 2021, the most important inflow of home migrants into any state. However by Florida’s requirements, it wasn’t that uncommon. Whereas the 2021 uptick was a much bigger quantity than any yr from 2011 to 2019, it was in step with the final pattern of increasingly folks transferring to Florida as the last decade wore on. And solely 73,129 extra home migrants moved to Florida in 2021 than in 2019, earlier than the pandemic.
After all, these newcomers to the Sunshine State could possibly be qualitatively completely different from their pre-pandemic predecessors: extra Republican, extra ideologically motivated. Sayfie says that, anecdotally, a number of current transplants have informed him that they moved to flee COVID-19 restrictions. “The rationale they’re coming is that they’re political refugees. They’re searching for refuge from the insurance policies of their dwelling states.”
However all of the outdated causes folks moved to Florida earlier than the pandemic didn’t go away in a single day, both. We couldn’t discover a scientific ballot asking folks why they moved to Florida, however the Tampa Bay Instances put out an open name for solutions to that query in 2022, and the commonest responses had been decrease taxes, inexpensive housing costs and good climate. That’s in step with analysis that has discovered that most individuals who transfer accomplish that for monetary, not political causes. (To make certain, “decrease taxes” counts as a political purpose to maneuver — nevertheless it’s not one which DeSantis can take credit score for, because the state structure has banned private revenue taxes since 1968.)
A number of respondents to the Tampa Bay Instances did cite coronavirus restrictions as a purpose for his or her transfer, so it’s potential that among the enhance in migration from 2019 to 2021 was due to DeSantis’s insurance policies. Alternatively, a number of respondents additionally cited their newfound skill to work remotely, which is one other potential rationalization for the 2021 spike. Total, it’s robust to say with any confidence that DeSantis’s COVID-19 coverage brought on a major variety of folks to maneuver to the state who wouldn’t have accomplished so in any other case, a lot much less an inflow of recent residents that was massive sufficient to vary the state’s political composition.
DeSantis has accomplished plenty of party-building
DeSantis in all probability had extra of an impression on Florida’s political hue by investing in marketing campaign subject operations to increase the state GOP. There are at present 525,418 extra registered Republican voters in Florida than there have been on the finish of 2018, and a few of that development may be credited to DeSantis. Shortly after his 2019 inauguration, he directed the state GOP to deal with registering extra Republican voters. The GOP’s internet enhance of greater than 40,000 voters that yr was the celebration’s greatest acquire within the yr earlier than a presidential election this century. Then, in 2020, the celebration added a contemporary document of almost half one million voters on internet. In 2021, DeSantis contributed $2 million to the registration push, and it paid off that November, when the variety of registered Republicans eventually surpassed the variety of registered Democrats. Lastly, in 2022, amid DeSantis’s reelection marketing campaign, the GOP capped off a powerful quadrennium by including 188,323 Republicans to the rolls on internet. You guessed it: That was probably the most for a midterm yr in no less than 20 years.
However as useful as DeSantis was to those efforts, he can’t take full credit score. Because the chart above makes clear, Republicans had been closing the registration hole with Democrats for fairly a while — and their efforts actually went into overdrive beginning in 2016, a few years earlier than DeSantis got here on the scene. Former President Donald Trump’s marketing campaign in all probability deserves kudos for the dramatic enhance in Republican registration in each 2016 and 2020.
And of their quest to take the lead in celebration registration, Republicans obtained the most important help from an unlikely supply: Democrats. Along with these 525,418 extra registered Republicans, Florida additionally has 299,808 fewer registered Democrats than it did on the finish of 2018 — regardless of the state’s inhabitants development. The Florida Democratic Get together has, for years, been in shambles, and so they have been unable to spend money on the form of registration efforts essential to fight pure attrition from the voter rolls. If the celebration had merely been capable of maintain regular on the 5,315,954 registered voters it had on the finish of 2020, registered Democrats would nonetheless outnumber Republicans statewide — regardless of DeSantis’s greatest efforts.
Hispanic voters didn’t swing simply due to DeSantis
You can also’t discuss in regards to the GOP’s current dominance in Florida with out speaking in regards to the important inroads they’ve made amongst Latinos. In line with Catalist, a Democratic-aligned information agency that makes use of the voter file to investigate previous elections, Hispanic help for Florida Democrats cratered in 2022. Former Rep. Charlie Crist, Democrats’ gubernatorial nominee, obtained simply 44 p.c of the Hispanic vote. Against this, former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton acquired 66 p.c of the Hispanic vote as just lately because the 2016 presidential race. That’s a giant deal in a state whose citizen voting-age inhabitants is 21 p.c Hispanic.
But it surely’s exhausting to say that Hispanic voters are transferring proper due to DeSantis. For one factor, the Republican shift began properly earlier than the 2022 marketing campaign. In 2020, President Biden obtained simply 50 p.c of the Hispanic vote in Florida, in response to Catalist, which accounts for a lot of the drop between 2016 and 2022. If anybody deserves credit score for this, it’s in all probability Trump, who appealed to Hispanic voters together with his personal push to reopen the economic system through the pandemic, in addition to with focused outreach to Florida’s numerous Hispanic communities. And naturally, Latinos’ rightward swing is a nationwide phenomenon, not only a Florida one. Nationally, Hispanic help for Democrats fell from 71 p.c in 2016 to 62 p.c in each 2020 and 2022.
That mentioned, Latinos did proceed to maneuver towards Republicans between 2020 and 2022 in Florida when they didn’t accomplish that nationally. That would have been due to DeSantis, or it may have been as a result of Florida’s Hispanic inhabitants is exclusive (whereas most Latinos nationally are Mexican American, Florida’s Hispanic neighborhood largely consists of individuals of Cuban, Puerto Rican and South American descent, who could have completely different political priorities).
Or there may not have been motion in any respect, and Republicans ended up with larger help amongst Latinos in 2022 just because many Hispanic Democrats in Florida simply didn’t trouble turning out to vote in 2022. In line with Florida Democratic information analyst Matthew Isbell, there have been 959,980 Latinos registered as Democrats in Florida on the time of the 2022 election, versus simply 728,027 who had been registered as Republicans. However solely about one-third of these Hispanic Democrats really voted, in contrast with greater than half of Hispanic Republicans, which meant that the precise voters contained extra Hispanic Republicans than Hispanic Democrats. In different phrases, plenty of DeSantis’s success with Latinos in 2022 was because of disparities in turnout.
Florida may not be that pink anyway
Dive into the turnout numbers for 2022 and a good larger downside for DeSantis’s narrative emerges. Loads of DeSantis’s success throughout the board was because of disparities in turnout. Total, Isbell discovered that 63.4 p.c of Florida’s registered Republicans forged a poll in 2022, however solely 48.6 p.c of its registered Democrats did. That 14.8-point turnout hole was means out of line with the 2016, 2018 and 2020 elections in Florida.
2022 noticed an enormous partisan turnout hole in Florida
Share of Democratic registered voters who forged a poll versus the share of Republican registered voters who forged a poll, in Florida basic elections since 2012
Election | Dem. Turnout | GOP Turnout | Hole |
---|---|---|---|
2012 | 72.0% | 78.0% | R+5.9 |
2014 | 50.1 | 60.4 | R+10.3 |
2016 | 74.2 | 81.1 | R+6.9 |
2018 | 64.4 | 71.0 | R+6.5 |
2020 | 77.2 | 83.8 | R+6.5 |
2022 | 48.6 | 63.4 | R+14.8 |
Neglect the query of whether or not DeSantis deserves credit score for Florida’s swing to the precise — this raises the query of how a lot Florida has swung in any respect. In any case, 2022 was just one election, and historical past is rife with examples of landslide victories in swing states that didn’t completely change the states’ political nature. (Take Nevada, which reelected then-Republican Gov. Brian Sandoval by 47 factors in 2014 in between voting for then-President Barack Obama by 7 factors in 2012 and Clinton by 2 factors in 2016.) There’s proof that Florida has been drifting towards Republicans lately, however that pattern predates DeSantis, and there was no signal earlier than 2022 that it might turn into a state the place Republicans win by 19 factors with any regularity.
Florida is a pink state, however not that pink
How Florida has voted in presidential and gubernatorial elections since 2000
Yr | Workplace | Dem. | GOP | Margin |
---|---|---|---|---|
2000 | President | 48.8% | 48.9% | R+0.0 |
2002 | Governor | 43.2 | 56.0 | R+12.9 |
2004 | President | 47.1 | 52.1 | R+5.0 |
2006 | Governor | 45.1 | 52.2 | R+7.1 |
2008 | President | 50.9 | 48.1 | D+2.8 |
2010 | Governor | 47.7 | 48.9 | R+1.2 |
2012 | President | 49.9 | 49.0 | D+0.9 |
2014 | Governor | 47.1 | 48.1 | R+1.1 |
2016 | President | 47.4 | 48.6 | R+1.2 |
2018 | Governor | 49.2 | 49.6 | R+0.4 |
2020 | President | 47.8 | 51.1 | R+3.4 |
2022 | Governor | 40.0 | 59.4 | R+19.4 |
Given all of the proof, it appears extra probably that DeSantis is “simply” a powerful candidate with a powerful political operation than a politician who has basically reshaped Florida politics. Even Sayfie, who does consider DeSantis has helped make Florida considerably redder, thinks 2022 will show to be an outlier. DeSantis obtained additional credit score from voters due to his anti-lockdown insurance policies through the pandemic, he mentioned, that future Republican candidates received’t profit from. “That excellent political storm is not going to occur once more.”