Business Insights: Global Markets, Strategy & Economic Trends
- Wired reported an internal talent database of roughly 40,000 V.I.P. entries, including L.G.B.T.Q.I.A. markings for 93 guests, naming Ricky Martin and Phoebe Bridgers.
- Earlier Wired reporting described extensive surveillance, including facial recognition and an alleged two year tracking of a transgender woman.
- M.S.G. Entertainment says the article falsely implied intent to identify, track, rank or discriminate against L.G.B.T.Q.I.A. individuals.
- The suit names Wired, Noah Shachtman, Maddy Varner and Katie Drummond, seeking damages and a correction or retraction.
- Leaked data from hacker group ShinyHunters came from a C.R.M., and the database assigns risk scores to about 400 V.I.P.s, some banned.
The owners of Madison Square Garden have filed a defamation lawsuit against Wired magazine, claiming an article it published this month had manufactured a “false narrative” that the company was tracking the L.G.B.T.Q. community for “discriminatory purposes.”
The article, published on July 9 and titled “Madison Square Garden Kept a List of Gay Celebrities,” describes an internal “talent database” maintained by the Madison Entertainment Corporation that contains information about roughly 40,000 V.I.P. guests from the business, tech, entertainment and sports worlds who frequent the arena in Midtown Manhattan.
The database also includes information about the race, gender identity and sexual orientation of a small number of those celebrities, according to the article’s authors, Noah Shachtman and Maddy Varner. Ninety-three guest entries are marked as “L.G.B.T.Q.I.A.,” including those for the singers Ricky Martin and Phoebe Bridgers.
Why exactly the venue notes this information in its database “is unclear,” the authors wrote.
Prior Wired reporting from Mr. Shachtman and Robert Silverman has described Madison Square Garden’s extensive surveillance operation, including its use of facial-recognition technology, and claimed that the security team put in place by its billionaire chief executive, James Dolan, tracked a transgender woman throughout the arena over a two-year period.
The M.S.G. Entertainment lawsuit argues that the July article and its promotion “falsely implied” that the arena, where the Knicks play and many stars perform, intended to “identify, track, rank, exclude or discriminate against L.G.B.T.Q.I.A. celebrities, artists, guests, fans and patrons because of their sexual orientation or gender identity.”
Instead, the “opposite is true,” according to the lawsuit, which claims that Madison Square Garden and “its affiliated entities” have contributed hundreds of thousands of dollars to Pride and L.G.B.T.Q. organizations while partnering with Pride-associated sports and youth programs.
Besides Wired and other affiliated corporate entities, the lawsuit also names Mr. Shachtman, Ms. Varner and Katie Drummond, the magazine’s global editorial director, as defendants.
The suit seeks compensatory and punitive damages as well as the “correction or retraction of the false and defamatory statements and implications,” among other remedies.
When reached for comment on Saturday, a spokeswoman for M.S.G. Entertainment referred to a Thursday news release from the company, which describes the July article as “unethical and inflammatory.”
Ms. Drummond said in a statement on Saturday that she was “proud” of the magazine’s work, adding, “I’m looking forward to continuing our accurate and newsworthy coverage.” In a separate statement, which the magazine posted online on Thursday, it called its reporting “accurate” and the lawsuit “baseless and ridiculous.”
The statement added: “We look forward to continuing our coverage of MSG, and on billionaire James Dolan’s use of technology across his entertainment empire. It’s one part of our wider mission and the critical job of journalists, now more than ever: holding power to account.”
Ms. Varner could not be immediately reached on Saturday, and Mr. Shachtman referred comment to the magazine, which had removed a paywall from the article following the lawsuit.
Beyond tracking some celebrities’ sexual orientations, Madison Square Garden’s talent database also assigns a “risk score” to roughly 400 V.I.P.s, according to Mr. Shachtman’s and Ms. Varner’s reporting.
For example, the rapper Fat Joe, a huge Knicks fan, is labeled “medium risk,” as is Anna Wintour. The hip-hop stars Freddie Gibbs and Lil Jon are “high risk,” while some celebrities, like the rapper Lil Tjay, are banned from the arena altogether.
The database was part of a much larger collection of company documents, including internal emails and other corporate information, released in June by the hacker group ShinyHunters, which often engages in cyberextortion.
The data was leaked after Madison Square Garden “failed to reach an agreement” over a ransom request from the group, according to three class-action lawsuits recently filed against the company.
In its lawsuit against Wired, M.S.G. Entertainment claims that the data stolen by ShinyHunters — including the information about some guests’ sexual orientations — was taken from a standard customer relationship management, or C.R.M., platform, “the purpose of which is to serve M.S.G.’s customers and to further inclusion,” including by extending invitations to L.G.B.T.Q.-related events.
Read the full article from the original source
