Faith & Reflection: Voices from the Black Church and Beyond
1
(ThyBlackMan.com) Sometimes, itโs amazing how two voices โ from different eras โ can still feel like theyโre singing your story. Beyoncรฉ and Patti LaBelle do that for me every time. Pattiโs soul-stirring power and Beyoncรฉโs fearless reinvention show us that truth and emotion never go out of style โ they just find new ways to hit you. Even now, with Beyoncรฉ riding high on her Cowboy Carter Tour, sheโs still channeling that same lineage of Black womenโs strength that Pattiโs been serving for decades.
This isnโt about whoโs better โ itโs about what happens when you line up their songs and let them talk to each other. So hereโs my list of six Beyoncรฉ vs. Patti LaBelle songs you should check out. May they hype you up, hold you when youโre hurting, and remind you thereโs always a song that understands exactly where you are.
1. โIf I Were a Boyโ (Beyoncรฉ) vs. โIf Only You Knewโ (Patti LaBelle)
Beyoncรฉโs โIf I Were a Boyโ stands out in her discography because of its raw honesty. The song strips away the glitz of Sasha Fierce, showing Beyoncรฉ as a storyteller willing to lay bare the double standards women face in love. That tender ache in her delivery makes it timeless โ thereโs a quiet strength in the way she holds back her power until the bridge hits. You can feel her frustration and wishful thinking all at once. Itโs still relatable in 2025 because the gender dynamics she exposes havenโt vanished. In fact, the song feels even more relevant in an era when relationship roles are constantly being re-examined.
The visuals for โIf I Were a Boyโ add another layer โ Beyoncรฉ plays a cop, flipping the script on the stereotypical โtough guyโ role. It makes you sit with the irony: how different would relationships look if men felt the same consequences women do? Even now, when she performs it live โ or when you revisit it during her Cowboy Carter Tour โ that stripped-down arrangement hits you right in the gut. Itโs one of those songs you put on repeat when you need a good cry and a reminder of your own worth.
On the flip side, Patti LaBelleโs โIf Only You Knewโ is pure, old-school soul magic. Patti sings like sheโs testifying โ her ad-libs feel improvised yet perfectly controlled. Whatโs so brilliant is how the songโs simple lyric โ wanting someone to know how deeply you love them โ becomes an epic journey through her vocal runs. In an age where songs often feel overproduced, Pattiโs performance is a masterclass in letting the human voice do the work.
The song still shows up in romantic playlists for good reason โ itโs tender but powerful. And if youโve ever seen Patti perform it live, you know she takes her time, letting the audience feel every drop of that longing. Compared to Beyoncรฉโs modern ballad, โIf Only You Knewโ feels like a warm vinyl hug, a reminder that some love stories never age โ and some secrets never stop needing to be told.
2. โLove on Topโ (Beyoncรฉ) vs. โNew Attitudeโ (Patti LaBelle)
โLove on Topโ is Beyoncรฉ in her feel-good, nostalgic bag. Itโs a deliberate throwback โ you can hear her channeling Michael Jackson and Whitney Houston, pouring her joy into those unstoppable key changes. Itโs fun, flirty, and full of vocal acrobatics that only she could make sound so easy. You canโt help but smile when you hear her voice keep climbing higher โ itโs that rare song that feels like the sun bursting through clouds.
Part of its magic is that itโs so performative โ when Beyoncรฉ brings it to the stage, the costume changes, the choreography, and that last run of key changes feel like sheโs showing off for the fans she loves so much. Itโs not just a song about romantic love โ itโs about celebrating how good it feels when people see your worth and keep lifting you up. It works today because it reminds you not to settle โ whether itโs in relationships or friendships. Your joy should always be at the top.
Pattiโs โNew Attitudeโ comes at self-love from a completely different angle. Where โLove on Topโ feels romantic and bubbly, โNew Attitudeโ is the theme song for a whole life transformation. From the second that synth hits, you want to pull out your power blazer and strut down the street like youโve left your old self behind. Pattiโs voice has that joyful rasp โ itโs like sheโs your big sister, pulling you out of your funk and saying, โGet up, get moving, and donโt look back.โ
Whatโs beautiful is that both songs encourage reinvention. โLove on Topโ is about being lifted up by love; โNew Attitudeโ is about lifting yourself up, no permission needed. Itโs why they still pair so well on a playlist today โ whether youโre falling in love again or falling back in love with yourself.
3. โHaloโ (Beyoncรฉ) vs. โSomebody Loves You Baby (You Know Who It Is)โ (Patti LaBelle)
โHaloโ has become Beyoncรฉโs signature ballad for a reason โ it blends pop accessibility with gospel sensibility. The songโs production feels like a church service wrapped in modern pop. When she opens up in the chorus โ โEverywhere Iโm looking nowโฆโ โ thereโs a sense of release, like sheโs exhaling all her fears and letting the light in. Even people who donโt usually listen to ballads get drawn in because โHaloโ is more than a love song โ itโs about faith in something bigger, whether thatโs a partner, yourself, or the universe.
And when Beyoncรฉ performs it live, it feels spiritual. The stage lights, the fans swaying, that big final belt โ youโre witnessing a pop star slip into preacher mode, reminding you that some loves really do feel heaven-sent. Itโs the kind of song thatโs gone viral on TikTok countless times โ newlyweds walking down the aisle, best friends surprising each other โ because everyone wants to feel that โyou save meโ moment.
Meanwhile, Patti LaBelleโs โSomebody Loves You Babyโ is the opposite kind of intimacy. Itโs warm, grounded, and deeply human. Where โHaloโ lifts you into the clouds, Patti keeps you rooted. Her delivery is conversational, as if sheโs right in the room with you, pouring tea and saying, โBaby, youโre loved. You donโt even know how much.โ Itโs soothing, the kind of song you play when youโre curled up under a blanket, needing that reminder that someone out there cares for you without conditions.
One of the most beautiful things about Pattiโs version is how it feels timeless โ the production doesnโt overpower her; it just lets her voice wrap around you like a hug. In 2025, both songs are still powerful. โHaloโ is what you play when youโre ready to fly. โSomebody Loves You Babyโ is what you play when you need to rest in the love you already have.
4. โRun the World (Girls)โ (Beyoncรฉ) vs. โLady Marmaladeโ (Patti LaBelle)
โRun the World (Girls)โ isnโt just a song โ itโs an attitude, a call to arms. When Beyoncรฉ dropped it in 2011, she reminded everyone that pop can be political and still bang in the club. The track is built for the stage: stomping beats, fierce dance breaks, and lyrics that feel like battle cries. Even if youโve heard it a million times, those drums still make you want to put your shoulders back and take up space.
Itโs not the easiest song to sing along to โ the melody is secondary to the message โ but thatโs what makes it brilliant. Itโs less about being pretty and more about being powerful. Watching Beyoncรฉ perform it live โ like she did during the Formation World Tour and in recent nods on the Cowboy Carter Tour โ you can see she means every word. Itโs become a rally anthem for generations of women demanding more.
โLady Marmalade,โ on the other hand, kicked down doors long before Beyoncรฉ took the throne. Patti and Labelle turned a taboo topic โ sex work โ into an anthem of sisterhood and sexual liberation. The โ70s funk production, the French hook, and Pattiโs sassy delivery made the song a cultural lightning bolt. Itโs no wonder it keeps getting covered and sampled โ you just canโt improve on that original magic.
Even now, when Patti performs โLady Marmalade,โ sheโs unapologetic. She makes you want to live out loud, embrace your sensuality, and not be ashamed of owning it. The song paved the way for artists like Beyoncรฉ to reclaim sexuality on their own terms.
Together, these two songs are a reminder that Black women in music have always been at the frontlines of cultural change โ breaking the rules, rewriting the narrative, and making sure the world knows who really runs it. Put them both on your playlist when you need a reminder to walk a little taller, speak up louder, and never dim your shine.
5. โIrreplaceableโ (Beyoncรฉ) vs. โOn My Ownโ (Patti LaBelle & Michael McDonald)
โIrreplaceableโ (2006) is Beyoncรฉ in her full grown-woman era, serving sharp wit and self-respect with every line. Itโs more than just a catchy hook โ itโs a reminder that heartbreak doesnโt have to break you. That acoustic guitar riff feels conversational and familiar, almost like a friend strumming chords while you vent. And that hook, โTo the left, to the leftโฆโ, is still iconic โ a clapback thatโs now part of pop cultureโs breakup lexicon.
What makes โIrreplaceableโ timeless is how universal it feels. Beyoncรฉ isnโt screaming or weeping; instead, sheโs calm, confident, and clear-eyed about what she deserves. Thereโs humor woven into the shade โ โI can have another you in a minuteโฆโ โ that makes you want to stand up a little straighter the next time someone doesnโt value you. Even now, nearly two decades later, youโll hear that line quoted on social media whenever someone kicks out a toxic ex or walks away from a bad deal.
Patti LaBelleโs โOn My Own,โ her beautiful duet with Michael McDonald from 1986, shows what happens when that raw breakup energy settles into bittersweet acceptance. The songโs power is in its honesty โ sometimes you really do end up alone, but that doesnโt mean youโre broken. Pattiโs verses bring the vulnerability, while Michaelโs husky tone gives the track a grounded sadness. Their harmonies in the chorus โ โOn my own, once again nowโฆโ โ feel like two people realizing they were never quite on the same page but still wishing each other well.
Whatโs special is how grown-up it feels. Where Beyoncรฉโs โIrreplaceableโ makes you slam the door, Pattiโs โOn My Ownโ lets you sit on the porch, look at that closed door, and say, โIt hurts โ but Iโll be fine.โ Play them together and youโll get the full spectrum: the fire of righteous anger and the wisdom of letting go with grace. Itโs proof that heartbreak songs donโt have to be all tears or all toughness โ the best ones, like these, hold both.
6. โFreedomโ (Beyoncรฉ feat. Kendrick Lamar) vs. โYou Are My Friendโ (Patti LaBelle)
โFreedom,โ from Beyoncรฉโs Lemonade (2016), is nothing short of a modern freedom hymn โ an anthem that straddles gospel revival and protest march. From the moment the beat drops, thereโs an urgency in Beyoncรฉโs voice โ itโs not polished pop perfection, itโs a raw, spiritual roar. Her vocals crack and strain in all the right places, like sheโs channeling centuries of struggle and survival. When Kendrick Lamar jumps in, it takes the track even higher โ his verse weaves through personal pain and systemic injustice, making it feel both intimate and universal.
What gives โFreedomโ its staying power is that itโs not just a song โ itโs a cathartic purge. Itโs the soundtrack for a generation still fighting, still hoping, still believing in liberation that hasnโt fully arrived yet. The live performances are even more powerful โ the stomping feet, the gospel choir, the sweat on Beyoncรฉโs brow. Sheโs not just singing about freedom โ sheโs fighting for it with every note. Even in 2025, itโs impossible to hear it and not feel something wake up in your chest.
Patti LaBelleโs โYou Are My Friendโ (1978) is a different kind of freedom song โ one rooted in the safety of community and the power of unconditional love. It starts like a prayer, gentle piano and Pattiโs soft, open delivery wrapping around you like a blanket. But when she hits that bridge, her voice climbs to the heavens โ the gospel training she grew up with on full display. You can practically hear the church pews creak and the congregation hum along.
Thereโs something so healing about this track. It reminds you that liberation isnโt just about marching in the streets โ itโs about knowing someone has your back when you come home, exhausted and hurting. The song has been covered by so many because itโs timeless โ the message that true friends are family is never out of date.
Put these two side by side, and you get the full picture of what freedom looks like for Black women artists: the public fight and the private circle. Beyoncรฉโs โFreedomโ is the cry that rattles walls; Pattiโs โYou Are My Friendโ is the hug that holds you up when your voice is tired. Both feel as necessary now as when they were released โ maybe even more so.
Every time I revisit these songs, Iโm reminded that good music doesnโt get old โ it grows with you. Listening to Beyoncรฉ and Patti LaBelle back to back is like sitting with two generations of wisdom, passion, and unfiltered honesty. One might be your mirror when youโre down; the other might be the hand on your back pushing you forward.
So the next time you need a soundtrack for your heartbreak, your glow-up, your late-night kitchen dance party, or that quiet moment when you just need to feel seen โ press play on these songs. Let Beyoncรฉ and Patti remind you that no matter what youโre facing, youโre not alone โ and your voice, too, deserves to be heard.
Staff Writer;ย Jamar Jackson
ย
Read the full article on the original source